Sydney WiFi & Computer Repair
Call致电
Case Studies案例研究 / Latest Case最新案例

Dodo 250M Fibre Kept Dropping Out in Chifley: Changing DNS Did Nothing, the Second Router Was Dialling PPPoE Too

Chifley的Dodo 250兆光纤频繁掉网:改DNS没用,问题是副路由器也在拨号

Share house · Chifley合租房 · ChifleyDodo 250M fibreDodo 250兆光纤6 people sharing6人共用Random dropouts频繁掉网Changing DNS did not help改DNS没有用Second router misconfigured副路由器配置错误

The first message was a wall of symptoms: dropping out, devices that would not connect, slow speed tests, and a list of everything they had already tried — including changing the DNS servers, which is the advice you find everywhere online. Six people share this Chifley house on a Dodo 250Mbps fibre plan with PPPoE and a TP-Link router. It read like a complicated fault. On-site it took one pass of link-by-link testing, and the culprit was the second router.

第一条消息看得人头大:掉网、设备连不上、测速慢,还附了一长串他们已经试过的方法——包括改 DNS,这也是网上到处都能搜到的建议。这是 Chifley 的一套房子,6 个人共用 Dodo 的 250 兆光纤套餐,PPPoE 拨号,TP-Link 路由器。听起来像很复杂的故障,实际上现场按顺序测了一遍就找到了:问题出在副路由器。

Where the network was breaking · two routers, both dialling网络在哪一环坏掉 · 两台路由器,都在拨号
Fibre / ONT光纤入户
250M
Main router主路由器
PPPoE ok
Cable into LAN port网线插在LAN口
wrong
Bottleneck瓶颈
Second router副路由器
dialling too
Bottleneck瓶颈
6 people's devices6人的设备
drop out

The main router dials PPPoE and hands out addresses for the whole house. The second router had never been reconfigured: it was still in router mode trying to dial PPPoE itself, and its uplink cable was plugged into a LAN port instead of the WAN port. That gives you two devices fighting over addressing on the same network — which shows up exactly as the housemates described: slow address assignment, devices that cannot connect, and connections that drop at random. No DNS setting can fix that.主路由器负责 PPPoE 拨号并给全屋分配地址。副路由器一直没有被重新配置:它还停在路由模式、自己也在尝试拨号,而且上联网线插在了 LAN 口而不是 WAN 口。结果就是同一个网络里有两台设备在抢地址分配——表现出来正好就是他们描述的那样:拿 IP 很慢、设备连不上、时不时断线。这种情况改多少次 DNS 都没用。

Why changing DNS was never going to help

为什么改DNS注定没用

DNS is the phone book that turns a website name into an address. Changing it can help when pages are slow to start loading but the connection itself is solid.
DNS 相当于把网址翻译成地址的电话簿。当连接本身稳定、只是网页打开慢时,改 DNS 有时确实有用。

How we isolated it on-site

现场怎么一步步定位

How we isolated it on-site现场怎么一步步定位
1
Wired into the main router and waited for the fault to appear有线直连主路由器,现场等故障复现
Slow to get an IP, speed itself normal拿IP很慢,测速本身正常
2
Plugged our own router and cable straight into the wall port用自带的路由器和网线直连入网口
Line, cable and provider all ruled out线路、网线、运营商全部排除
3
Reset the main router, kept WAN only, unplugged every LAN cable重置主路由器,只留WAN口,拔掉所有LAN口网线
Network stable with one router alone只留一台路由器时网络稳定
4
Logged into the second router's admin page登录副路由器后台检查
Still set to PPPoE, cable in a LAN port仍是拨号模式,网线插在LAN口
5
Reconfigured it, reconnected both, tested many devices改成正确配置,主副重连,多设备测试
Still clean when we checked back an hour later一小时后回访仍无复现
The method is boring on purpose: prove each link with gear you know is good, and change one variable at a time.
方法故意做得很笨:用你确定没问题的设备逐环节验证,每次只改一个变量。

A second router: router mode vs access point mode

副路由器:路由模式 vs AP模式

A second router: router mode vs access point mode副路由器:路由模式 vs AP模式
Router mode (what it was)路由模式(当时的状态)Access point mode (what it needed)AP模式(应该的状态)
Dials PPPoE是否拨号Yes — a second dial-up on one line会——同一条线上出现第二个拨号No — the main router dials不会——由主路由器拨号
Hands out addresses是否分配地址Yes, competing with the main router会,和主路由器打架No, the main router does it不会,交给主路由器
Uplink cable goes to上联网线插哪Was plugged into a LAN port当时插在 LAN 口WAN port, or LAN-to-LAN in AP mode插 WAN 口,或 AP 模式下 LAN 对 LAN
What users see用户感受Slow to connect, random dropouts连接慢、随机掉线One stable network across the house全屋一个稳定的网络
If your house has more than one router, this is the first thing to check.
如果你家不止一台路由器,这是第一个要查的地方。
Result最终结果

Root cause: the second router was still in router mode dialling PPPoE, with its uplink cable in a LAN port — two devices competing to run the same network. Neither Dodo, nor the fibre line, nor the DNS servers were involved. After reconfiguring it and reconnecting both routers, all six housemates' devices connected normally, and a follow-up an hour later found no recurrence.

根因:副路由器仍停在路由模式、自己也在 PPPoE 拨号,上联网线还插在 LAN 口——两台设备在抢同一个网络的控制权。跟 Dodo、跟光纤线路、跟 DNS 都没有关系。改成正确配置、主副重新连好之后,6 位室友的设备都恢复正常,一小时后回访没有再复现。

Related

相关链接

Facing something similar?

遇到了类似的问题?

Call or message us — 90% of messages get a reply within an hour.

打电话或留言——90%的消息1小时内回复。

Call 0470 219 120 Send a Message